Skip to content

Does it make sense to compare “the Spanish flu of 1918” with the Covid-19 epidemic?

Many articles, statements and videos have compared the current pandemic with the 1918 pandemic, also known as the “Spanish Flu”. They even state that we can learn important lessons about confinements, masks or even “second waves”.

But does this comparison make sense?

What was different at that time?

There are many differences between 1918 and the present:

  • We lived in the early days of modern science and the level of knowledge about infectious diseases was very scarce compared to what we have today. Many of the measures were taken intuitively and without scientific evidence.
  • The medical health care capacity was incomparably lower (hospitals, doctors, nurses).
  • Effective drugs and treatments were limited. There were, for example, no antibiotics – a crucial tool for the treatment of bacterial infections and, in this case, of secondary infections resulting from the disease caused by the virus. Penicillin was only discovered ten years later (1928).
  • Global mobility nowadays is incomparably superior, and the contact with all kinds of infectious agents is also higher. It is therefore more difficult for major breaks in immunity to occur in any parts of the globe.

Historical background

The spread of the flu was facilitated by the mobilization of large masses of the population due to the war (1st World War). Thousands of soldiers, many of them wounded or sick, disseminated the disease.

Specificity of the evolution of the Pandemic

Although it is common for different waves to occur in epidemics, the existence of three major waves in the “Spanish flu” over a period of eight to nine months was exceptional. Besides the particular historical context, one of the hypotheses that has been advanced is the mutation of the virus.

Differences between the viruses

SARS-CoV-2 is a coronavirus, while the H1N1 of the Spanish flu is an influenza virus. Although they have many similarities, namely in the form of transmission and type of genetic material (RNA), they also have some differences. Perhaps the most relevant is the fact that the influenza viruses undergo much more mutations and thus make it difficult to create a strong cross immunity – with other viruses of the same family. This does not happen with coronaviruses.

The main agent behind the deaths

Contrary to the general perception, most deaths will not have been caused by the virus. Although it is common for flu deaths to be caused by secondary infections, this was the last pandemic in which there were no antibiotics to fight them. This seems to have been decisive.

According to analyses of lung tissue collected at the time, and the review of information collected from 8,398 autopsies, there is strong evidence that the vast majority of deaths resulted from bacterial infections and not the virus itself.

Extent of the tragedy

Another big difference is the impact caused by both pandemics. It is estimated that the Spanish flu killed about 50 million people. Considering the population at the time, this means that about 3% of people died.

At this moment, the official number of deaths by Covid-19 represents about 0.015% of the population.

In addition, the Spanish flu affected a lot of young and healthy people, namely under five years old and people between twenty and forty.

The number of Covid-19 deaths in young people is rare. The majority of deaths occur among the population over 80 years old, or among people with one or more previous diseases.

Some even suggest that the available data support that the epidemic is strongly accentuated by a late seasonal effect in the northern hemisphere, and by a previous mild flu season.

Other pandemics

It is surprising to continue comparing a pandemic that occurred more than 100 years ago, with such evident differences, and of which we have very unreliable data, with the Covid-19. Since the “Spanish flu” three more epidemics have been declared: the “Asian flu” of 1957-1958 (H2N2), the “Hong Kong flu” of 1968 (H3N2 virus), and the “swine flu” of 2009 (H1N1pdm09).

The “Asian flu” victimized about 0.038% of the world population at the time, the Hong Kong flu of 1968 (H3N2 virus) approximately 0.028%, and the “swine flu” which, ended up having an estimated lethality lower than the seasonal flu, may have victimized only 0.005% of the population. Currently, the official records of “death by Covid-19” correspond to approximately 0.015% of the world population.

About these pandemics we have much more reliable data and the circumstances are much more similar. Surely we have more to learn from them than from the “Spanish flu”.

References:                                     

Álvaro Sequeira. Spanish influenza. Internal Medicine Vol. 8, N. 1, 2001. History of medicine. 

An Introduction to Applied Epidemiology and Biostatistics. Lesson 1: Introduction to Epidemiology, Section 11: Epidemic Disease Occurrence. CDC (USA)

COVID-19 deaths compared with “Swine Flu”. Centre for Evidence-Based Medicine (CEBM- Oxford University). April 9, 2020

Emerging Infectious Disease. 2006 Jan; 12(1): 15–22.

David M.. Morens, Jeffery K. Taubenberger, Anthony S. Fauci. Predominant Role of Bacterial Pneumonia as a Cause of Death in Pandemic Influenza: Implications for Pandemic Influenza Preparedness. The Journal of Infectious Diseases. Oxford University Press

Jeffery K. Taubenberger&David M. Morens. 1918 Influenza: the Mother of All Pandemics

Maria D. Van Kerkhove, Siddhivinayak Hirve, Artemis Koukounari, Anthony W. Mounts. Estimating age‐specific cumulative incidence for the 2009 influenza pandemic: a meta‐analysis of A(H1N1)pdm09 serological studies from 19 countries. Wiley Online Library, 2013. 

Merriam-Webster Dictionary. Cross-immunity.

Principles of Epidemiology in Public Health Practice, Third Edition

Sucharit Bhakdi: On the difference between Corona and Flu. Youtube. 2020. 14: 18 (diferença entre corona e influenza)

Worldometers. Information. World-population by-year

1918-pandemic. Pandemic resources. CDC (USA)

1957-1958-pandemic. Pandemic resources. CDC (USA)

1968-pandemic. Pandemic resources. CDC (USA)

2009-h1n1-pandemic. Pandemic resources. CDC (USA)

Gostou deste artigo? Apoie-nos no Patreon!

Comentários

No comment yet, add your voice below!


Add a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Sign up for our newsletter and receive our Pandemia Covid-19 study for free - Knowledge and perceptions of the Portuguese population